US edition of the world's oldest magazine
Holy Smoke

How Biden’s cardinals are trying to shut down free discussion

May 28, 2021

Listen & Subscribe

America’s Catholic bishops are furiously divided among themselves this week, after a liberal faction led by the Biden loyalists Cardinals Cupich of Chicago and Wilton Gregory of Washington tried to stop them discussing the question of whether the radically pro-choice president of the United States should be allowed to receive Holy Communion.

The US conference of bishops is scheduled to address the whole question of the Eucharist at its meeting next month. The plan is to prepare a document that will finally decide whether American bishops will enforce the Vatican’s ban on actively pro-abortion Catholics receiving the sacrament while in a state of ‘grave sin’, as the Church puts it.

As I say in the new episode of Holy Smoke, It looks as if most of the 290 active bishops are ready to enforce such a ban — goaded by Joe Biden’s increasingly hardline support for completely unrestricted abortions, and his plans to remove constitutional protection for pro-life public employees.

But doing so would anger and embarrass a Democratic president — and that’s the last thing that his bishop, Cardinal Gregory, wants to do. Gregory is a former member of the McCarrick circle, and like most of Uncle Ted’s ex-allies is ideologically close to the Democratic Party. Incidentally, it was then-Cardinal McCarrick who championed the cause of pro-choice politicians receiving communion, quietly suppressing the clear ban issued by Cardinal Ratzinger, reiterated when he was pope.

As the influential Catholic publication the Pillar revealed this week, Gregory and Cupich have mustered 60 bishops to sign a letter telling the president of the USCCB, Archbishop Jose Gomez of Los Angeles, to kick the Eucharistic discussion into the long grass.

This has provoked an incandescent reaction from the Archbishop of San Francisco, Salvatore Cordileone, who describes it as an attempt to stifle free discussion among the bishops. ‘I cannot tell you how aggrieved this makes me feel,’ he told the Pillar.

The controversy is particularly nerve-wracking for the US bishops because they don’t know where the Pope stands on this question. Francis is a big fan of the current Argentine president, Alberto Fernandez, who has recently legalized abortion in the country. When the Pope and the President met in Rome this month, the subject apparently didn’t even come up.

For more thought on the wider ramifications of this crisis — and it’s a big crisis — listen to the episode.

About the show

Holy Smoke

Holy Smoke

The most important and controversial topics in world religion, thoroughly dissected by a range of high profile guests. Presented by Damian Thompson.

More from Holy Smoke

  • December 25, 2021

    Why the Catholic Church is facing chaos this Christmas

    Pope Francis renewed his campaign against the Latin Mass this month, permitting his liturgy chief Archbishop Arthur Roche to issue all manner of threats to clergy celebrating the ancient liturgy. This “clarification” has been greeted with horror by bishops around the world, including many who aren’t keen on the old rite. This episode of Holy […]

  • September 22, 2021

    Has Pope Francis thrown Joe Biden under the bus on abortion?

    Say what you like about Pope Francis, but he’s incapable of giving a boring in-flight interview. Last Wednesday, coming back from Hungary and Slovakia, he was asked about the problem of pro-abortion Catholic politicians receiving Holy Communion. He immediately launched into a ferocious denunciation of abortion, describing it as homicide, saying there was no middle […]

  • May 13, 2021

    The legal harassment of today’s Christians is the last legacy of the Soviet Union

    Today’s Holy Smoke podcast is about the increasingly brutal bullying and silencing of people — especially Christians — who hold the ‘wrong’ opinions on controversial topics. A culture of censorship is becoming ever more deeply embedded in public institutions not just in Britain but also throughout Europe. In London last month we witnessed the nasty […]

  • February 20, 2021

    Can the United States be transported back to Christendom?

    This week’s Holy Smoke examines the fragmentation of American Catholicism following the election of pro-choice Catholic Joe Biden. It focuses on the strangest current of thought among the many conservative Catholics calling for an urgent change of approach in order to confront what promises to be an authoritarian liberal administration. It’s called integralism, a label […]

  • January 29, 2021

    How the Vatican tried to suppress criticism of the new President

    Cardinal Blase Cupich, the ambitious left-wing archbishop of Chicago, must have imagined that Joe Biden’s inauguration last week would be a moment to savor. He and a small number of his liberal colleagues, known as ‘the Biden bishops’, have been working tremendously hard to make sure that, once their candidate was elected, any mention of […]

  • December 23, 2020

    Goodbye to Catholic Ireland

    Rarely has a religious culture collapsed more rapidly than that of Catholic Ireland, which just 30 years ago seemed indestructible. Incredibly, it looks as if the Irish Church will have ordained more bishops than priests in 2020. It goes without saying that the Irish abuse crisis has hugely accelerated the process of secularisation in what […]

  • December 18, 2020

    Beethoven’s spirituality: a conversation with Sir James MacMillan

    It’s the 250th anniversary of the birth of Ludwig van Beethoven. In this episode of Holy Smoke, Damian Thompson is joined by his fellow composer Sir James MacMillan to discuss a side of Beethoven that the postmodern artistic establishment prefers to ignore: his unwavering faith in God and the surprisingly strict morality that arose from […]

Web-only content Copyright © 2021 The Spectator // Magazine content Copyright © 2021 The Spectator